Wednesday, October 23, 2024. No, we're not going to rewrite history and paper over it with lies.
We're
going to start with the nonsense brigade. Naomi Klein's going to be
our focus. I'll give you her Tweet but we need to wind up to her.
John
Rick MacArthur -- goes by "Rick" -- is someone I've known for years. I
doubt the young people in the left (under 30) have any idea who he is.
But for awhile there, he was being pimped like crazy. And he did do
some good work -- especially at the start of the Iraq War. And it was
his magazine, that published Naomi Klein's "
Baghdad Year Zero." A very
important work about the Iraq War.
And people turned on Rick. Before they did, I lost respect for him and made that clear here.
I
knew him for years. I knew his mother was French. On his father's
side, they were a historically important American family.
And
then one day Rick let's slip that he'd just voted. Oh. Who for? Wait. He
voted in the French elections. And he voted in the US elections.
I
do not approve of that, I do not support that. This is not a new
position for me with regards to Elon Musk. You should not be allowed to
vote in more than one nation's elections. It's just not fair and it's
not really about democracy or one person one vote.
Rick
can tell a funny story. He's a good person. But I walked away on that
day -- and noted it here -- and then came his refusal to support unions
much later -- the magazine staff wanted to unionize. That angered
others -- the union issue -- and I understand that but I take the other
issue seriously as well.
Naomi Klein.
She was on DEMOCRACY NOW! yesterday and I have no idea why.
I do not need her discussing US elections.
I think with her especially that she's crossing a line.
Years
ago, during the days of AIR AMERICA RADIO, she appeared on Al Franken's
show. And Al, as usual, didn't know what he was talking about. The
issue turned to travel -- specifically entering the US. And had that
ever been a problem for Canadian Naomi Klein?
Her
answer would have had great importance if she'd answered it -- if she'd
answered it honestly. But she didn't. She avoided the issue.
Now
the Iraq War was raging and some US service members were self-checking
out. Jeremy Hinzman, Darrell Anderson, Joshua Key, Ivan Brobeck and many more.
And they needed support.
And, in Canada where they went, Naomi did support them. She'd sign a petition. She donated to a group.
And for some people that might be enough.
Excuse me for not being satisfied.
Naomi's
father left the US due to Vietnam. He was a War Resister. And if
Naomi had shared that -- especially on Al Franken's neoliberal show --
it could have made a difference in the way some saw the War Resisters.
Naomi
had Canadian citizenship, yes, but being born to parents from the US,
she also had US citizenship. So, no, Al Franken, Naomi didn't have
trouble entering the United States.
That's the answer and that is why. But she wouldn't say that. She just dodged the question.
This was early 2005 and it would have made a difference.
But she didn't want to tell the truth. So we did here.
And I have never cared for her championing US politicians when elections rolled around.
I'm
all for War Resisters and have helped many over the years. But you
leave the country, then you leave the country. I've forever noted here
that the US should not allow Cuban exiles into the US if the whole point
is for them to use our country as a base to attack Cuba.
You're Cuban and you want to live here? Great. Welcome. You're an American now. Let's all get along.
But
that's not happening if you're here feeding your resentment against
Cuba. And that's true, for me, for any exile. Don't come to this
country in order to plot against your country of origin.
Now on Naomi, should she be a US citizen?
I
don't believe in dual citizenship. I've made that clear here for two
decades. But her mother and her father elected to leave the United
States. Why are we now, as a country, saying she's a citizen of the
United States? I'm not trying to be rude or mean.
She didn't grow up here. (Her father can't return unless he wants to go to prison.)
I
think Naomi is often exceptional. But I also believe in Ellen
Goodman. In fact, I believe in the former BOSTON GLOBE columnist even
more. She's smarter than so many and has a lot more common sense.
She'd started out on the chat and chews -- those public affairs programs
where they bring you and you end up weighing on everything.
But no one can weigh in on everything.
And she grasped that and stopped doing the chat and chews as a result.
No
one can speak in an informed manner on every topic. When Texas
Governor Greg Asshole went after Latino citizens, I noted here that I
really wanted to avoid the topic and that I wanted to do that because I
knew nothing about it. But then I'm looking around and left media --
independent media -- is avoiding the topic completely. My plan had been
to just highlight reports on the topic. I was not qualified to comment
on it. But to get qualified -- because no one, not even Juan Gonzalez,
was weighing in -- I had to ask Texas community members to do a
conference call with me, I had to talk to a member of the US Congress
from Texas that I personally knew, I had to speak to one of the women
targeted -- her home raided -- and then I still wanted another
conference with community members in Texas and bothered poor Sabina with
non-stop questions even after that.
So Naomi Klein appears on DEMOCRACY NOW! and she was there to talk about Gaza. And she's informed on that.
But then Amy wanted her to weigh in on the US presidential election.
Why?
She's
not an expert on that. She doesn't live in the US. There are
Americans who would argue she shouldn't have citizenship (including
those who would make the argument -- I did not -- that the minute her
father refused US military service and left the country, he should not
have been able to pass on citizenship -- Naomi was born long, long after
Vietnam). She's not qualified to speak on
US electoral politics. She has no knowledge base. She has nothing
worth sharing -- her 'tears of joy' on election night piece for THE
PROGRESSIVE back in 2008 was nothing but political porn at its worst as
she watched from a distance people that she could not hear speaking and
people that she had never met became people that she just knew what they
were thinking -- just knew it,
really, really, really knew it! That's political porn -- the sort that
James Wolcott rightly took Peggy Noonan to task for years ago.
Naomi made some general statement before sharing her concern: Kamala had abandoned her base!!!
STFU.
Not since your bad book -- now out in soft cover -- where you didn't
understand the concepts of twinship even though it went to the heart of
your book's argument -- have you looked so stupid.
Kamala abandoned the base!!!!
Just f**k the hell off.
That is not what happened.
I
tore Kamala apart over the wording of an answer she gave on Gaza to the media and I got a
call from a friend in the administration stating I was attacking the
only one defending Gaza. I noted that in a roundtable and I backed off
from attacking Kamala. I didn't write about it here. I believed my
friend but I didn't make the case for it here -- this was long before
the Biden-Trump debate. And I went back and forth on the topic. Talk
about it here in a snapshot and maybe risk outing the friend? Didn't
want to do that. Nor did it really matter. Kamala was going to
advocate in private but it wasn't going to have any real impact because
that's all she could do. She was not the president. Nor is she today.
But
what ended up happening is that she became the nominee. I'm glad she
did. I think she'd be a great president. And I'm willing to hold her
feet to the fire the same way I've done every other politician -- and
journalist -- in the two decades this site has been up. If she becomes
president, I'll hit hard. I don't pull punches. I like Naomi Klein but
I don't pull punches on her.
So
the Abandon Biden movement already existed. And then he stepped
aside. And without taking a breath, it became Abandon Harris. And it
became more and more nonsense and bulls**t -- to the point that these
Gaza Freaks are now harming Palestinians because Americans are recoiling
from the Gaza Freaks. So they trashed her in public and they attacked
her for this and that. Including the nonsense of a speaker they wanted at the DNC convention.
Naomi
may not know all this happened, she doesn't live in the US. But it
happened. And electoral politics not being an area of expertise for her
(campaign politics was a field of emphasis for me both as an
undergraduate and as a graduate student), she may not understand how
political conventions work in the US. I have no idea how they work in
Canada. I wouldn't pretend to.
But
the reality is that a spot to speak at a convention is a big deal and
everyone wants it. An unknown would-be-US-Senator from Illinois got to
speak at the 2004 convention -- Barack Obama -- but a sitting US
senator, Hillary Clinton, who was not just a former First Lady but
someone who repeatedly raised a lot of money for the Democratic Party
was initially denied. No female politician or female activist was going
to be allowed to speak in prime time. For those too young to remember,
this was back in the day when Simon Rosenberg was advocating for
Democrats to abandon support for abortion rights and for LGBTQ+ rights. Those of us
who did believe in reproductive rights had to demand Hillary get to
speak. This was a months long process.
And Hillary was a nationally known Democrat. She had star power.
So
you idiots who thought you were going to elevate some woman who held a
local office? You're idiots. You could have had six months to attempt that
-- you didn't, you had about two weeks -- and it wouldn't have worked.
You would been better off getting behind an activist for Palestinian
rights -- an activist with a name which means Bella Hadid, for example.
Even then, in two to three weeks, you wouldn't have achieved anything
most likely. But you would have had a better shot with someone like
Bella.
And it wasn't just
that your local politician was an unknown on the national stage so she
wouldn't have helped get viewers tuned it, it's also the jostling that
takes place among the politicians who all want to be on stage and
speaking in prime time. They would never had let your local politician
onstage for that reason. They wouldn't want Bella on as well but they
would have surrendered to the notion because Bella is news and attracts
an audience.
But instead of grasping that they were pursuing a losing strategy, they trashed Kamala.
That's all they ever did.
Kamala
doesn't have months, you idiots and assholes on the left. She had to
assemble a team and get a campaign going in an instant. And she did
that.
And she doesn't have time to woo people who say they won't vote for her.
Equally
true, for all the lies from Amy Goodman and others, Gaza Freaks are not
the base of the Democratic Party. They're not the base of anybody's
party. I suspected that in July but we've spoken to groups in every
state now except Alaska and Hawaii. And Gaza Freaks are on their own.
(Gaza Freaks are not supporters of Palestinians. Supporters of
Palestinians would be doing anything to keep Trump out of the White
House. Gaza Freaks are purity freaks with infantile yet sterile minds.)
A
lot of Republicans do not want Trump. That was clear in the
primaries. That's an audience Kamala could pick some voters from. How
many? I have no idea.
But
if I were managing her campaign, I would've told her to forget the Gaza
Freaks. No matter what she did, it was not enough for them.
Acknowledging the suffering in Gaza in her convention speech and the
need for a cease-fire didn't make the Gaza Freaks stop attacking her.
In
a normal campaign, you'd be wasting your time trying to court those
crybabies. In a much more limited campaign? She doesn't have the
time. She'd be wasting her time based on the reality that nothing she
has said has been good enough for these Gaza Freaks.
You have cut yourselves out of the conversation. That is on you.
A
campaign is about winning votes. When all you did was attack the
candidate, there's no reason for the candidate to try to woo you.
Donald Trump's not going before LGBTQ+ audiences, seeking their votes.
(Melania will speak to them provided they pay her at least $200,000 --
for her, that's campaigning).
You screwed yourselves out of a seat at the table.
Naomi's
yammering away like an idiot because, on this topic, she is one. She
doesn't understand electoral politics, she doesn't understand US
politics, she doesn't live in the US and she's looking down from a cloud
at those of us working our asses off to try to save our democracy and
protect our citizens. Guess what, Naomi, we can't exit the US for
Canada because we don't have dual citizenship, we don't have your
privilege.
I'm
not here to let reproductive rights suffer again. Every woman in the US
should have the same medical options in every state. That's
healthcare. My healthcare is not a 'state's right.' That's bulls**t.
Every same-sex couple should have the same rights and that includes full
citizenship. That awful case built on lies found the Supreme Court
creating two kinds of citizenship -- full citizenship and second class
citizenship. If you're straight, you can shop where you want and expect
to be treated fairly. If you're gay or lesbian, you can be refused
service. I'm not here to let our public education -- the thing that
binds us together as citizens (it certainly isn't home schooling) --
fall apart because Trump wants to destroy the Dept of Education. I'm
not here to let some racist rewrite history by refusing to allow future
generations know about slavery and what a scar it left on our country
and how much damage it did to people living under it. I'm not here so
that Sabina, in Dallas, TX, a US citizen, has to worry that the police
are going to come up to her when she goes to the Mercado on Jefferson
and demand proof of citizenship and, if she doesn't have it on her, be
pulled off the street.
I'm not here to watch Donald Trump achieve his goal of dismantling our Constitution.
I don't have the luxury of sitting this election out or the stupidity of voting for a con artist like Jill Stein.
I also am fully aware that the Palestinians are screwed if Trump gets back in the White House. 100% screwed.
Naomi's
taking a lot of flack for that segment. Some are appalled that she
said vote for Kamala and some are appalled by this or by that. I'm
appalled by her 'creativity' when it comes to what went down. Again,
she wasn't here. So I'm not surprised she's wrong. But I am surprised
she was stupid enough to talk about that she didn't witness and that she
clearly did not study.
If she reads the
comments left on her Tweet that we noted above, I would encourage her to
click on the ones commenting that are balling her out for saying vote
for Kamala. A lot of them are right-wingers pretending otherwise.
There is the White guy from the UK pretending to be an American, a White
guy who reTweets Epstein lies about Kamala as he works hard to pimp
Trump but pretends to be Green in his comment, there's the outraged
Muslim who, woops!, endorses Trump every day on his Twitter feed, there
are a whole lot of fakes who want to come off differently in their Tweet
slamming her than what they actually are.
If
Kamala becomes president -- and I hope she does -- I'm not gong to be
tossing kleenexes at her -- Marilyn Monroe tried to house train her dog
and would bat the dog with a kleenex -- I'm going to be hitting hard and
I'm not going to fret over my language or my approach. I do get that
Naomi Klein means well so in this case, I will stress again, she's
exceptional on many things.
I'm not making
that claim about Michael Moore who I can't stand. Yeah, I saw him on
MSNBC giving his Muslims in Michigan analysis.
It was lies and he knows it.
That's why he starts with 2020.
Reality:
This is the group that overwhelmingly voted Republican until 9/11
results in Bully Boy Bush scapegoating and attacking them. With him
long gone from the White House, they have been repeatedly edging to the
Republican Party. In this decade, they're repeatedly embraced book
banning and attacks on LGBTQ+ people. It's not the Disneyfied picture
that Michael Moore paints.
There are progressive Muslims in Michigan. As with any religion, there are also fundamentalists.
"She's
told us that we're irrelevant" lies Naomi Klein. That's not how this
unfolded. I'm not in the mood for stupidity, justifications or lies.
Meanwhile,
Kamala's everywhere. Pennsylvania and Wisconsin alone yesterday.
Let's note this from her Brookfield, Wisconsin campaign event with
former US House Rep Liz Cheney:
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Good evening, everyone. Good evening.
MR. SYKES: And, Vice President, wel- — welcome back to Wisconsin.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: It is good to be back. You — you know, I — so, Tony Evers.
MR. SYKES: (Laughs.)
THE VICE PRESIDENT: That’s funny about his playlist. Is it really that long? (Laughter.)
MR. SYKES: No.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Okay.
Every time I — I land in Wisconsin — almost every time, Tony Evers,
the governor, will meet me on the tarmac. And because I did live in
Wisconsin when I was five years old, every — (applause) — he will say,
“Welcome home.” So, I do feel and have a connection to Wisconsin and
feel a sense of connection.
MR. SYKES: Actually, we all have connections to Wisconsin, which —
which makes this event, I think, so important, with 15 days to go.
So, let’s just dive right into all of this. There are actually undecided voters out there.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Yeah.
MR. SYKES: And there are undecided voters here.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Yeah.
MR. SYKES: People who have never voted for a Democrat. Moderates,
conservatives who voted for people named Bush and Cheney and Ford and
Reagan —
MS. CHENEY: Yay. (Claps.) (Laughter.)
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Yeah.
MR. SYKES: And — and Bob Dole. Wow, that’s a — that’s throwback, isn’t it?
But I guess the question is: What is your pitch to them? Why should
they do something they’ve never done before? Why should they cross over
party lines and vote for you?
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Well, I start from the belief, based on the
lived experience, that the vast majority of us have more in common than
what separates us.
I also know that you all are here spending time that you could be
spending doing a number of other things, with all of the obligations you
each have, and you are here because we, together, love our country. We
love our country, and we believe in the foundational principles that
are at stake in this election.
I believe that when we think about who we are as the American people,
there is more we have in common than what separates us when we think
about what is at stake in terms of our democracy, rule of law, the
Constitution of the United States, national security, the standing of
our country in the context of the world. All of that is at stake.
And I will share with you, Charlie, when I was in the Senate for —
for those four years that I was there, my favorite committee was the
Senate Intelligence Committee, and I’m going to tell you why. We would
walk into that meeting in a SCIF, which is a — a secure room. We’d have
to leave our cell phones outside. The press, with all due respect,
were not allowed in. No cameras.
People would walk in, Democrats and Republicans, take off their suit
jacket, roll up their sleeves, and we’d dispense with who was a
Republican and who was a Democrat. We were all Americans. We were all
in that room with one singular purpose: to concern ourselves as our
highest priority with the security and well-being of the United States
of America.
I think those things are at stake in this election. (Applause.)
MR. SYKES: Congresswoman Cheney, you know how hard this is, though.
You know how hard it is to break away from tribal loyalty to do
something you haven’t done before. So, I’d like you to address that as
well.
Lindsey Graham was on television yesterday saying, “What do you
‘Never Trump’ Republicans — you know, what — what are you thinking of?
How could you possibly do all of this?”
There are a lot of people who are listening to us who may be
disillusioned with what’s happening with the Republican Party, but they
w- — they don’t they — they — they’re afraid of paying the price,
because there is a cost to all of that.
So, what do you say to those Americans?
MS. CHENEY: Well, don’t listen to Lindsey Graham. Number one. (Laughter and applause.) It’s good life advice, actually.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: (Laughs.)
MS. CHENEY: But what I say is that, at the — what undergirds
everything that we are as a nation — everything that we are as a nation
is the rule of law and it’s our Constitution.
And when you — when you look at what Donald Trump did after the last
election, when you look at the cruelty that’s involved in someone who
watches an attack on the United States Capitol, an attack conducted by
people in his name, and refuses for over three hours to tell the mob to
leave — I mean, I really — people just need to think about what that —
that — that’s — that’s depravity. He watched the attack happen, and
people kept asking him, “Please tell the people to leave.” And law
enforcement officers were being brutally beaten and the Capitol was
being assaulted, and he would not tell people to leave for over three
hours.
That cruelty is the same cruelty that we see when he lies about the
federal government’s disaster response, when he puts people’s lives at
risk because he won’t tell the truth. He’s a man who’s unfit to be the
president of this good and honorable and great nation.
And so, I’ve spent a lot of time working — before I was elected to
Congress — in countries around the world that — that weren’t free or
where people were trying to achieve their freedom, and I know how
fragile — how fragile this — this can be, how fragile democracy can be.
And so, in — in this election, we have a choice. We have the choice
of somebody, in Vice President Harris, who you know is going to uphold
the rule of law. You know that she’s going to lead this country with a
sincere heart. You know that she is going to always be thinking about
what is best for this nation. We might not agree on every issue, but —
but she is somebody that you can trust and someone that our children can
look up to. And I think it’s so important for us to cast the vote for
Vice President Harris this time around. (Applause.)
MR. SYKES: You know, Vice — Vice President, I w- — I was thinking
about one of your social media posts recently where you go through all
the things that Donald Trump has bailed out of: that he won’t debate
you, that he won’t — that he won’t do interviews, that he’s refusing to
release certain information. And — and you asked an interesting
question: What is he hiding?
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Yeah.
MR. SYKES: So, what, in fact, is he hiding?
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Well, I — I wonder what is he hiding. I also
wonder what his staff is trying to hide by — by preventing or suggesting
he not debate me again, not do these interviews. It is the norm, as
you know, that presidential nominees will do a “60 Minutes” interview.
He has refused to do that. He is pulling out of interviews left, right,
and center.
And I think that we — what we see about him in public, whether it be
his rallies or, as you said, the — the — would it — would it be called a
— just a solo dance? I — I don’t — I — (laughter).
MR. SYKES: I don’t know that is has a — I don’t even know if it has a name to it.
MS. CHENEY: “Dance” is really generous.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: What — (laughs). Yes.
MR. SYKES: Yeah, the word “dance” would be generous.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: What — what that was.
I — I think it does lead us and it should lead us to observe that he is increasingly unstable.
But you don’t have to take my word for it. Listen to the people who
know him best, the people who worked with him in the White House, in the
Oval Office, in the Situation Room: his former chief of staff; two
former secretaries of Defense, his secretaries of Defense; his former
national security advisor; and, of course, his former vice president.
And they have each talked about the — the chief of staff — that Donald
Trump has contempt for the Constitution of the United States.
Not only has that been said by a former chief of staff of the former
president, but we know he has openly talked about his intention to
terminate the Constitution of the United States.
I have taken that oath six times: as district attorney twice —
elected and reelected; as attorney general of the largest state, in
California, twice; as a United States senator; and actually now as vice
president. And the congresswoman and I have talked about that. That is
an oath one must take seriously. It is a duty to defend and honor and
uphold the Constitution of the United States.
He has said he would terminate it. Anyone who wants to be president
of the United States should never again be able to stand behind the seal
of the president of the United States, having said they would terminate
the Constitution of the United States. (Applause.)
And, again, most recently, the report is that the former chairman of
the Joint Chiefs of Staff, a decorated general, said of Donald Trump
that he is “fascist to the core.” These are the people who know him
best, people who worked with him.
And so, yes, we can talk about that moment on stage of the music and
all that, but I think it’s very important that we acknowledge, and I
have said publicly, Donald Trump is an unserious man, and the
consequences of him ever being president of the United States again are
brutally serious — brutally serious.
I — to — to the congresswoman’s point, I have now, as vice president
of the United States, met over 150 world leaders — presidents, prime
ministers, chancellors, and kings — many of them, multiple times; we are
on a first-name basis — most of them allies in connection with NATO,
and — and I’ve met with them in connection with our standing, rightly,
with Ukraine. The world is watching this election, and our allies are
worried, because the reality is that when we, as the United States of
America, walk in these rooms around the world, we walk in chin up,
shoulders back, with the earned and self-appointed authority to talk
about the importance of democracy and rule of law.
And being a role model — this is a room of role models — we know, as a
role model, people watch what you do to see if it matches up to what
you say.
One of my very real fears, Charlie, to be candid, is I hope that we,
as the American people, fully understand how important America is to the
world. I hope we really, really understand that — (applause) — because
this is about what will happen to and — and with us as Americans, but
it will impact people around the world.
MR. SYKES: Let me follow up on that, Congresswoman, because I was on
a podcast recently with — with another pundit who was saying that she
was afraid that America was sleepwalking into authoritarianism, that
American voters were not sufficiently alarmed. And as the vice
president just said, the former chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff
just said that Donald Trump was the most dangerous threat facing the
country.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Yeah.
MR. SYKES: Do Americans — in this last 15 days, do they understand
that? And what has to happen in the next two weeks for them to really
understand the danger?
MS. CHENEY: Yeah, I — I think that they — I think they do. And, you
know, one of the things I — I remind people is that although not every
Republican who is casting a vote for Vice President Harris will say
publicly that they are — there’s clearly, you know, a threat associated
with that in some instances — but — but millions will. And — and they
will do that for a whole range of reasons, but — but what you mentioned
is so important.
I mean, when I think about — you know, I — the first time I ever
voted was for Ronald Reagan. I’ve known presidents well. Obviously,
particularly, I know a vice president well — (laughter) — in addition to
Vice President Harris. And — and I watch how our presidents have
operated. And even when there have been presidents that we have
potentially disagreed with on issues, they’ve respected the
Constitution.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Yeah.
MS. CHENEY: I mean, think about the 2000 election and how close that
was and what Vice President Gore did in — in his concession speech and
in ensuring that we had the peaceful transfer of power.
And so, I — I would just urge people — again, you don’t have to — to
take my word for it, but — but look at what the people closest to Donald
Trump are saying about him. Look at the testimony of the leaders of
his Justice department, the leaders of his campaign, the most senior
officials in his White House. Look at their testimony in front of the
Select Committee. You know, they’re the ones that — that told us
everything that we know about his plan to overturn the last election,
about what he did watching the attack from his dining room.
We’ve never faced a threat like this before, and I — I think it’s so
important for people to realize this republic only survives if we
protect it, and that means putting partisan politics aside and standing
up for the Constitution and for what’s right and loving our country
more. (Applause.)
MR. SYKES: Do — do you — do you think we’ll be hearing more from
some of those folks in the next 15 days — the generals, the chiefs of
staff, the people who really understand exactly how unfit Donald Trump
is?
MS. CHENEY: I do. I also think that — you know, that they have been very clear so far.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Yeah.
MS. CHENEY: I mean, you’ve had — you’ve had hundreds of national
security officials who served in Republican administrations endorse the
vice president —
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Publicly, yeah.
MS. CHENEY: Yeah. And all of the things that — that — you know, the
fact that these people aren’t endorsing — the fact that Vice President
Pence, who was the most loyal person there was to Donald Trump — he
won’t endorse him because he knows Donald Trump asked him to violate his
oath of office.
Now, that should also give you a lot of pause about J.D. Vance. J.D.
Vance is there because he will do what Donald Trump wants, and that
makes him a particular danger to the republic as well.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: And — and I’ll add to that point: Understand
also what happened in the last few months when the Supreme Court
essentially told the former president he will be immune from anything he
does in office. So, whereas, before, there was at least some threat of
consequence and accountability, that no longer exists.
And to the congresswoman’s point, imagine Donald Trump — based on
everything we know about him and everything we see now and before —
imagine him with no guardrails, because all of those folks who worked
with him before, they’re not — those who held him back, who attempted to
ensure that he would follow the law are no longer there. And — and we
have the Supreme Court decision, so the stakes are very high.
MR. SYKES: Okay. Let’s go to the audience for some questions. We —
we have some undecided voters who have some questions for you, Madam
Vice President.
Let’s go to Lisa Brockman from Madison. Lisa is a small-business owner.
Q Hi.
MR. SYKES: Good evening.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Hi.
Q Thanks for taking my question. I have a question on reproductive freedom.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Yeah.
Q And I am — come from a conservative, Christian, pro-life family,
and I was a Republican until Donald Trump’s presidency. (Laughs.)
Like most Americans, I believe in a woman’s right to choose. And with
the overturning of Roe v. Wade, my 21-year-old daughter now has fewer
rights than her mother or her grandmothers.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Yeah.
Q I no longer recognize the Republican Party. They have
introduced bills for everything from restricting birth control to
bringing homicide charges for abortion. It is such an extreme, radical
agenda by any standards, and it seems less about the unborn and more
about controlling women.
So, my question is: What are your thoughts on this extremism, and how
can we restore those fundamental human rights that have been taken away
from the American women?
MR. SYKES: Thank you.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: So, to your point, when Donald Trump was
president, he hand-selected three members of the United States Supreme
Court with the intention that they would undo the protections of Roe,
and they did as he intended. And now there are at least 20 states in
our country that have criminalized health care providers, to your
point.
I mean, in Texas, the — the law provides for prison for life for a
doctor, nurse, health care provider for doing what they believe is
health care and in the best interest of their patient.
Punishing women. I was actually just this week, just a few days ago,
in the state of Georgia with the mother of a young woman who died
because of Georgia’s abortion ban, and she had to go to another state.
And it’s a long and very tragic story that did not have to be.
And here’s how I think about this issue. One does not have to
abandon their faith or deeply held beliefs to agree that the government —
these folks in a state capitol, much less Donald Trump — should not be
making this decision for her. If she chooses, she will talk with her
priest, her pastor, her rabbi, her imam, but not the government.
And — and I also have found, though, since the two years that the
Dobbs decision came down, that this happened, I have had conversations
with a number of people who were opposed to abortion and remain opposed
to it but did not intend for the harm that we are seeing to happen. And
I think as this has — this decision came down and we are seeing the
harm, there are more and more people who are agreeing that this should
not be the government making this decision for women and their families.
And the way that we will address this is, eventually, Congress needs
to pass a law restoring those protections, and we need to agree that, in
our society, you know, we should not have laws that are treating people
in a way that is causing such harm.
I’ll give you another example of the harm that is going on. I
started my career as a prosecutor. I have prosecuted everything from
low-level offenses to homicides. But one of the reasons I became a
prosecutor is because, when I was in high school, I learned that my best
friend was being molested by her stepfather. And so, I said to her,
“You have to come live with us.” I called my mother. My mother said,
“Of course,” and she did. And I made a decision early in my life that I
wanted to do the work that was about protecting vulnerable people.
There are some of these bans that include no exception for rape or
incest. I have specialized in those kinds of cases. And the — the
notion that we would tell a survivor of a crime that is a violation to
their body that they have no right to make a decision about what happens
to their body next — I mean, I think that’s just unconscionable. I
think it’s immoral.
And so, this is one of the issues that is at play. And when this
issue has been on the ballot, since the Dobbs decision came down, in
so-called red states and so-called blue states, the American people have
voted for freedom. (Applause.)
MR. SYKES: Congresswoman Cheney, I’d like to get your thoughts on this as well.
MS. CHENEY: Yeah. You know, I am — I’m pro-life, and I have been
very troubled, deeply troubled by what I have watched happen in so many
states since Dobbs. And I have been troubled by the extent to which you
have women who, as the vice president said, in some cases, have died,
who can’t get medical treatment that they need because providers are
worried about criminal liability.
You know, we’re facing a situation today where I think that it’s an
untenable one. And I think that as we deal with issues like this one,
having a president who understands how important compassion is, who
understands that these shouldn’t be political issues, that we ought to
be able to have these discussions and say: You know what? Even if you
are pro-life, as I am, I do not believe, for example, that the state of
Texas ought to have the right, as they’re currently suing to do, to get
access to women’s medical records.
I mean, there are some very fundamental and fundamentally dangerous
things that have happened. And — and so, I think that it’s crucially
important for us to find ways to have the federal government play a role
and protect women from some of the worst harms that we’re seeing.
But — but, again, I just think that if you look at the difference in —
in the way that Donald Trump is handling this issue — you know, Donald
Trump, at one point, called for criminal penalties for women. Now, you
know, he — he’s been now trying to — to, you know, sort of be all over
the place on this issue, although he expresses great pride for what’s
happened.
And — and I think the — the bottom line on this, as on so many other
issues, is, you know, you just can’t count on him. You cannot trust
him. We’ve seen the man that he is. We’ve seen the cruelty. And
America deserves much better. (Applause.)
MR. SYKES: Thank you. Thank you, Lisa.
So, we — we have another question. Carolyn Mitchell from Wauwatosa has a question for the vice president as well.
Q Hi. I have concerns about the strength and the health of the
Medicare and the Social Security system. There have been a lot of
suggestions for improving or protecting it, some of them raising the age
for full acceptance of Social Security. There’s also the idea that we
would end the cap on — on the Social Security tax. There is also the
suggestion that we raise the tax rate on both Medicare and Social
Security. And, of course, the last one is to reduce the benefits.
So, my question for you is: How can we protect the health of both Social Security and Medicare without reducing the benefits?
MR. SYKES: Thank you.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: So, first of all, thank you for your question.
Actually, just today, I believe it was — within the last 24 hours or so —
an independent review of Donald Trump’s policy on Social Security has
indicated that, under his policy, Social Security would become insolvent
in six years.
And what I and you and, I think, most of us know is that we have
many, many seniors in our country where their Social Security check is
their only form of income. It’s everything and the only thing they have
to live on, to pay rent, groceries, all of that. And so, we must
protect Social Security.
If you look at Donald Trump’s
Project 2025, the — the plan that they have if he is elected — or
reelected president, it — it would attack Social Security. It would
attack Medicare.
And back to the point about just what is
in the interest of dignity. The president of the United States should
have as one of their highest concerns the dignity of the American people
and, in particular, those who have lived a productive life, who deserve
to be able to retire and go into their senior years with the dignity of
not worrying about whether they’re going to have a roof over their head
or be able to eat.
So, my plan includes what we need to do
to strengthen the solvency of Social Security. It includes what we’re
going to need to do and work with Congress to make sure we’re putting
more into it. And it cannot be about cutting benefits, because right
now, those benefits are barely adequate as it is.
What we
must also do is continue to strengthen Medicare around what we’ve been
working on, which is to allow Medicare to negotiate prescription
medication costs for our seniors.
So, in the last four
years, we have now capped the cost of insulin at $35 a month for
seniors. This is a huge issue for so many who have otherwise either
taken a bus trip to Canada to try and get their prescription medication —
you’re smiling; you know what I’m talking about — or — not that you
have; I’m not suggesting that. (Laughter.) I’m not suggesting that.
And we’ve also capped the cost of — of prescription medication at $2,000
a year for our seniors, understanding, again, that this is a related
issue, which is what is causing our seniors to be on the verge of
bankruptcy and — and homelessness, by the way.
The other work that we have to do is to deal with home health care and how Medicare is covering that.
So, part of my plan is — right now, the only way that there will be
coverage for home health care is, generally speaking, Medicaid, which
means that the family or the individual would have to spend down all of
their savings to be able to be eligible for Medicaid. And, frankly, I
think it’s just — that’s — that’s wrong, and it’s — it’s just wrong.
You know, I took care of my mother when she was sick, and the work that
needs to happen to support our seniors to be able to stay in their
home, to be able to live a life with dignity should include that we will
pay attention to the fact that not everybody can afford that help, not
everyone has a family member who can do it.
And so, my plan includes having Medicare cover home health care work
for seniors — (applause) — so that you can stay in your home, for
example, and have someone who can prepare a meal and help you put on a
sweater. But the — the core point being dignity and understanding that
we should not have a society that allows or requires our seniors to — to
go into poverty in order to qualify for the care that they may need
that, I think, we — most would agree — should provide. (Applause.)
Thank you.
MR. SYKES: And we have another question from the audience, from Dan —
Dan Voboril, who is a retired school teacher, taught at MPS, and now
lives in Waukesha. Again, a genuinely undecided voter, I understand.
Q Thank you. Good evening.
MS. CHENEY: Come on, Dan. (Laughter.)
Q What did you say?
I was told I was going to be an alternate, so I was a little worried about getting my question. But —
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Take your time. Take your time.
Q This is a question that — I actually retired from MPS, but I
currently teach, and I teach at a private Catholic school. I’m a
Catholic, but I’ve also been pro-life, pro-choice depending. But I have
five daughters, and I think it’s my duty to continue — with the
children I teach as well — to see that we need to respect women, and
I’ve really come to the conclusion that this toxicity that exists is
just rather embarrassing. And as a lifelong Republican, who I thought
your father would be a great president —
MS. CHENEY: Thank you.
Q — not to say George wasn’t, but — (laughter) — but I’ve come to
this realization, and it’s — it’s been very difficult. So, I’m just —
my big question was, for the future of my children and also students
that I encounter and try to show that we have to have some kind of
civility like we did back in the — the ‘80s, when Ronald Reagan and Tip
O’Neill, of course, could talk about things and solve problems, and now
it’s trying to get one better than the other.
And so, I’m
just wondering, in your position now, how to convince people like me,
who some of my siblings might be questioning what I’m doing here, but —
(laughter) — I — I think, like you said, we have to be courageous, and
that’s what I’m trying to be. And so, what do you think we can do in
the last 15 days — or you can, Madam Vice President — what you can do to
try to get some of these people to cross over? I know you already said
that some of them probably won’t say who they’re voting for, but — or
something I could take with me to say, “This sounds very good,” or, “We
got to at least listen to this.”
MR. SYKES: To reduce the toxicity? Is that —
Q Yes.
MR. SYKES: Okay.
MS. CHENEY: Yeah, I — I think that — that, you know, you’ve really put
your finger on something that’s so important, and you see it as a
teacher. You know, any of us who are around young children — I see it
as a mom. My kids aren’t so young anymore, but — but, you know, the —
when they look at how elected officials and, in particular, how Donald
Trump is conducting himself now, that’s — that’s not — that’s not a
lesson that anybody would look up to.
And — and I think
about it often from the perspective of the men and women who’ve worn the
uniform of our country and who have sacrificed so much for our freedom,
all of us have an obligation to be worthy of that sacrifice.
And in this — (applause) — you know, in this moment, there — there
are millions of good and honorable people who Donald Trump has just
fundamentally betrayed. And — and I think it’s so important for — for
people to think about this from the perspective of, you know, the
decision to give somebody the power of the presidency means that you’re
handing someone the most awesome and significant power of any office
anywhere in the world, and — and you have to choose people who have
character, choose people of good faith.
You know, the — the
framers knew this. The framers knew that — that it was so important
that, you know, we take an oath but that also, fundamentally, you had to
have people of character. And Donald Trump has proven he’s not one of
those people by his actions.
So, you know, what I — what I
say to people is, look, for us to get back to a time where we are
actually having policy debates and discussions and disagreements, we
have to protect what undergirds all of this, and — and what undergirds
all of it is the Constitution. And we have to be willing to say, as a
nation, “We’re better than partisanship.”
We know — and I
say this as someone who spent a lot of years engaged in partisan battles
and — and there are important debates we have to have. But if — if we
allow someone again — if we give him the power again to, you know, do
all of the things he tells us he’s going to do — he says he’ll terminate
the Constitution; he says he’ll deploy the military against the “enemy
within” — that — that is a risk that we just simply can’t take as a
nation. And — and I think that, you know, this vote, this election
cycle, this time around has to be about so much more than partisanship.
And I will just end this by saying: And I also know because I have
spent time with Vice President Harris, because I have come to understand
what she believes about how she will govern, that she will be a
president for all Americans, that she’s committed to listening and
committed to having viewpoints, some of which, you know, come from
different ends of the political spectrum.
And — and if you
think about how you conduct, you know, your life outside of politics,
how we all conduct our everyday lives, those are the kinds of people
that you trust. Those are the kinds of people you can work with. Like,
if you wouldn’t — if you wouldn’t hire somebody to babysit your kids,
like, you shouldn’t make that guy the president of the United States.
(Laughter and applause.) I mean, that’s, like, pretty basic.
MR. SYKES: So — so —
MS. CHENEY: Thank you. Thank you.
MR. SYKES: Madam Vice President, that — this question goes to the
heart of our discussion tonight, because it’s almost — it is not about
politics. It’s not about left versus right. We’re talking about the
culture and the impact, the coarsening of the culture, the way in which
we have been taught to fear and hate one another, and how our —
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Yeah.
MR. SYKES: — debates have just devolved into sort of trolling one another. How do we get back from that?
THE VICE PRESIDENT: So, I think that Dan raised — and, Charlie, your
point is — is really also hitting on we have to tap into and — and
rejoice, frankly, in the spirit of who we are as Americans. And we are
an ambitious people. We have aspirations. We have dreams. We are
optimistic by nature. And we, I think, value certain qualities in our
leaders.
To your point as — being a teacher, all of — those
of us who are parents or parent in any form, the — the notion over the
last several years coming from Trump and those who follow him, meaning
people like who he’s running with — not his voters, but just others —
the notion that the measure of the strength of a leader is based on who
you beat down is just wrongheaded.
I think most of us would
agree that the — that the real measure of the strength of a leader is
based on who you lift up. I think most of us would agree — (applause) —
and most of us would agree that it is — when we talk about character,
it is the sign of strong character to have empathy, to have some level
of concern and care about the well-being of other people and then to do
something about that.
And I think there’s so much about this
election that calls into question whether we are on a track with a
Donald Trump as president to actually teach and to — and to show our
children our definition of a leader, and is that it.
One of
the issues that I think has resulted in the kind of toxicity that you
have been describing is that he tends to encourage us as Americans to
point our fingers at each other. That’s not in our best interest. The
vast majority of us have so much more in common than what separates us.
We are stronger as a nation when we are working toward a common goal, at least on the most basic, fundamental priorities.
And I think in this election, you can look at, for example, how he
presents in his — in his events to know that he really does not have a
plan for America that is about investing in our future, investing in our
children, investing in — in our economies and new industries, investing
in our relationships around the world. It’s all about himself and his
personal grievances. And do we want a president of the United States
who spends full time plotting revenge while they sit in the Oval Office
or a president who is actually focused on the American people?
I would also say, as a — as a point that I think the congresswoman
exemplifies in so many ways, the strength of our democracy requires a
strong two-party system. It really does. (Applause.) It requires that
we have healthy debate — that we have healthy debate based on — you
know, based in logic and fact and that we — we debate it out — have
good, vigorous debates — have a good fight over policy. That’s good for
democracy. But not to point our fingers and call each other names over
trivial, petty grievances.
So, I think all of that is at
stake in this election, and — and tapping into the commonalities that we
have around some of these fundamental principles, I think, is going to
be key.
MR. SYKES: Well, that’s why the stakes are so high,
right? Because the presidency is a role model, but America is a role
model to the rest of the world.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Yes.
MR. SYKES: So, in the very short amount of time we have left,
Congresswoman Cheney, just talk a little bit more about the — the stakes
for the world. We haven’t talked about the stakes for the future of
Ukraine, NATO, of all the other democracies who are looking to us.
MS. CHENEY: They’re so, so high, Charlie. And, you know, America’s
safety and security depends upon America leading, and it depends upon
allies.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Yeah.
MS. CHENEY: And when you have someone who is erratic and chaotic and unstable, that puts all of us at risk.
I — I tell people often — you know, I spend a lot of time working on
national security issues. And when people that I know in the — in the
Republican Party tell me they might be considering voting for Trump from
a national security perspective, I ask them: Go look at his national
security policies. Please, go look at them, because what he’s proposing
in terms of withdrawing from NATO; welcoming Vladimir Putin to attack
our NATO Allies; praising — he — he praises Kim Jong Un, the leader of
North Korea, and President Xi of China and Putin of Russia. And if you
listen to him, he doesn’t just praise those people generally. He
praises them for their cruelty —
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Yep.
MS. CHENEY: — for their tyranny.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: Yep.
MS. CHENEY: That’s not who we are as a nation. It’s not who we are.
And the world needs us to be better. And our own security and our
own freedom requires that we have a president who understands America
has to lead and that our strength comes both from our greatness and also
from our goodness. And that’s Vice President Harris. (Applause.)
MR. SYKES: And you have the last word.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: And — and just to — thank you. Thank you.
MR. SYKES: You get the last word.
THE VICE PRESIDENT: But — but just as a point of emphasis on this
important point: Understand that this is an individual, Donald Trump,
who is easily manipulated by flattery, and we’ve seen that. We’ve —
don’t forget he — he dared to even consider vi- — inviting the Taliban
to Camp David. Remember all this. The love letters with Kim Jong Un.
Let’s remember what we just most recently — what was reported. During
the height of COVID, Americans were dying by the hundreds a day. Nobody
could get their hands on COVID tests. You remember what that was.
During that time, he secretly sent COVID tests to Vladimir Putin for his
personal use.
On the issue of Ukraine, he says, “Oh, well,
I’d solve that in a day.” Well, I don’t think we as Americans think
that the president of the United States should solve an issue like that
through surrender, and understand that’s what would happen.
(Applause.) Understand that’s what would happen. Vladimir Putin would
be sitting in Kyiv if Donald Trump were president.
And
understand what that means as — so much that our allies understand, and
that’s why they’re concerned about this election. If — if Putin were to
get away with invading the sovereignty and territorial integrity of
Ukraine because America, the leader in bringing the allies together in
standing for fundamental international rules and norms, like sovereignty
and territorial integrity — if Vladimir Putin got away with that, you
think he wouldn’t march next right into Poland and the rest of Europe?
Because Donald Trump wants to please somebody that he considers to be a
strongman, who he admires?
So, on this and so many issues, the stakes are extremely high.
But I — I would say this as — as a final point for now. This is not as
much an issue of what we are against as what we are for. And I’ll end
my point where I started: We love our country, and our country is worth
fighting for. (Applause.) And that’s how I think of this.
We — our — our democracy will only be as strong as our willingness to
fight for it. And you all are taking your time out of your lives to be
here because we, I think, agree on that among the most fundamental
principles at stake.
And I thank you for the time you’ve taken, and I hope to earn your vote, by the way. (Laughs.) (Applause.)
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
MR. SYKES: And we have 15 days to make a decision.
Thank you all for coming here to (inaudible). Thank you,
Congresswoman Liz Cheney. Vice President Kamala Harris, thank you so
much. (Applause.)
And you had Eminem and Barack Obama in Detroit yesterday.